Semiahmoo RNG Gas Production and Refinery Project

Background Information

In recent years, the global push towards sustainable energy sources has gained momentum, prompting innovative solutions to address environmental concerns. One such approach involves the injection of Biogas or Renewable Natural Gas (RNG) into existing fossil natural gas distribution networks like Fortis. While proponents argue that this method contributes to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and fosters a transition towards cleaner energy, skeptics view it as a form of greenwashing, asserting that it merely perpetuates the dependence on non-renewable resources in view of the minimal percentage of renewable gas that will be included in the main fossil gas network (typically a maximum of 5-15%). This discourse delves into the arguments for and against the injection of Biogas or RNG into the fossil natural gas system, scrutinizing the validity of claims used by its supporters like Andion and Semiahmoo First Nations surrounding its environmental benefits.

Act Now!

Reduced Greenhouse Gas Emissions:

Proponents argue that injecting Biogas or RNG into fossil natural gas systems facilitates a decrease in overall greenhouse gas emissions, as these renewable gases are derived from organic waste and thus have a lower carbon footprint.

Utilization of Existing Infrastructure:

Advocates emphasize the practicality of leveraging existing natural gas infrastructure for the distribution of Biogas or RNG. This approach minimizes the need for extensive overhauls, making the transition cost-effective.

Promotion of Circular Economy:

Supporters contend that the use of Biogas promotes a circular economy by converting organic waste into a valuable energy resource. This, in turn, reduces dependence on finite fossil fuel reserves.

Counter Arguments Against Renewable Natural Gas:

Methane Leakage:

Detractors argue that the injection of Biogas or RNG may inadvertently lead to yet more methane leakage during production, transport, and distribution. Methane, a potent greenhouse gas, could offset the purported environmental benefits.

Greenwashing

Skeptics assert that promoting Biogas as a "green" alternative within the existing fossil natural gas infrastructure may delay the adoption of more comprehensive renewable energy solutions. This, they argue, amounts to greenwashing rather than addressing the root causes of environmental degradation.

Resource Competition

Critics express concerns about the potential competition for resources, particularly agricultural land, between the production of feedstocks for Biogas and food production. This may exacerbate existing challenges related to food security.

Give Your Feedback Today

The Extended Discussion around Renewable Natural Gas from Waste and the Andion Semiahmoo First Nations Biogas Project in South Surrey / White Rock BC :

Trucking and Transportation Issues:

Transporting household and animal waste over long distances to RNG refineries poses significant challenges. The carbon footprint associated with the transportation of such waste undermines the environmental benefits touted by proponents. This raises questions about the overall sustainability of the process. Reversing trucks offloading during off-peak traffic times will also cause noise nuisance for local residents.

Emphasis on Waste Reduction:

Critics argue that instead of investing in RNG refineries, more efforts should be directed towards reducing food waste at its source. Education and initiatives aimed at minimizing waste generation in households and businesses can have a more direct and sustainable impact on the environment.

Light Pollution Concerns:

In the midst of deliberations surrounding the environmental implications of Biogas or Renewable Natural Gas (RNG) injection, an often-overlooked aspect demands attention - light pollution. Detractors raise a valid concern regarding the potential adverse effects of RNG refineries on the night sky. The luminous output from these facilities has the potential to contribute to light pollution, disrupting the natural darkness of our nights. This interference not only poses challenges to local ecosystems, potentially affecting nocturnal animals and flora, but it also compromises the celestial views for communities in close proximity. The preservation of our connection to the night sky, a cultural and environmental asset, is an aspect that should not be sacrificed in the pursuit of cleaner energy solutions. Striking a balance between technological progress and the preservation of our natural surroundings is imperative in ensuring a sustainable and harmonious future.

Greenwashing and Disproportionate Expenses:

Detractors emphasize that RNG refineries may serve as a form of greenwashing, diverting attention from the need to transition to cleaner energy sources. The resources invested in building and maintaining these facilities could be more effectively used to advance renewable energy technologies with a higher return on investment.

Odor Problems and Safety Hazards:

Concerns about potential odor problems from the processing of organic waste in RNG refineries are raised by opponents. Additionally, the handling of biogas involves potential safety hazards, particularly if not managed with strict adherence to safety protocols.

Conclusion

Conclusion: The injection of Biogas or Renewable Natural Gas into fossil natural gas systems is a multifaceted issue with a range of environmental, economic, and social considerations. While proponents tout its potential as a green energy solution, the arguments against this approach underscore the complexities and potential drawbacks. Addressing issues such as transportation challenges, emphasizing waste reduction, avoiding greenwashing, mitigating safety hazards, and ensuring suitable locations for refineries are crucial steps in evaluating the true sustainability of this method. As we navigate the path towards a greener future, a holistic and critical examination of the entire process is essential to make informed decisions that align with long-term environmental and societal goals.

For a deeper understanding about Renewable Natural Gas, and whether it is really a Good or Bad Idea - read this article. Then in an effort to counteract the heavy advertising budget employed by Fortis and Andion to influence the general public to support the Semiahmoo RNG Project, read this article about why renewable natural gas is a Bad Idea in BC.